When Turkish Personal Muslum Ozdemir died throughout a navy operation in Iraq Final month, a disturbing story emerged. He got here from Kahramanmaras, the epicenter of the twins earthquakes That claimed the lives of greater than 50,000 individuals in nearly 10 provinces on February 6 final yr, and survived the catastrophe himself.
It did not take lengthy for the media to find that Ozdemir’s household, who misplaced their dwelling within the earthquake, was still lives in a tent nearly a yr after the catastrophe. The Kahramanmaras governor’s workplace disputed the photographs. It emphasised that not one of the province’s displaced individuals wanted to dwell in tents anymore: “Now we have given a container unit to every earthquake sufferer.”
Nonetheless, residents responded by saying that Ozdemir’s household had taken refuge within the tent as a result of the small container they had been allowed to dwell in risked being set on fireplace each time they tried to warmth it. The entire incident was a reminder of that Circumstances in Turkey’s earthquake zone stay acute and largely ignored by the media.
A number of humanitarian staff and specialists just lately visited the realm and issued warnings one after one other container cities, constructed with good intentions, had been depressing.
The models would leak water from the roof, or flood throughout heavy rain. There was mud all over the place within the dwelling areas, and the danger of fire was very excessive, which made everybody really feel uncomfortable. Entry to water is offered, however stays burdensome for a lot of, whereas employment continues to linger as a broader subject.
But in Turkey you do not hear a lot about these circumstances, or in regards to the individuals who undergo from them. Their plight is essentially absent from native media. Whereas that ought to be stunning, it is not. Only a month after the earthquakes, the catastrophe and its victims started to slide from public consciousness.
First, a crisis inside the opposition alliance over who ought to face President Recep Tayyip, Erdogan dominated the media in March. This was adopted by the parliamentary and presidential elections in Might. A brand new cupboard and new financial coverage adopted.
The earthquakes and their survivors had been barely seen — even on social media — when the three-month milestone arrived.
It was an enormous change from the 1999 earthquake that struck Izmit, 120km southeast of Istanbul, killing nearly 19,000 individuals. The media protection then lasted for no less than a yr, and other people had been reminded of the disaster many times for years.
However right now’s fast-paced media setting, which can be largely authorities managed, consumes vital matters and replaces them with one other inside hours.
The earthquake’s toll is grimmer, past the lack of life. The federal government says 227,000 buildings items destroyed or seriously damagedtogether with historic church buildings, mosques, historic websites, castles and different sights.
Authorities set up no less than 215,000 non permanent container houses in disaster-affected provinces, the place a whole lot of hundreds of earthquake victims reside. It has additionally supplied rental help to 349,000 households and supplied sizzling meals and different companies to greater than 4 million individuals every single day.
Nonetheless, reconstruction efforts are continuing slower than anticipated. Erdogan himself promised in March that his authorities would construct and ship to victims 319,000 houses in a yr, and pledged to construct a complete of 650,000 houses sooner or later.
— Gazete Pencere (@gazetepencere) January 13, 2024
His new Minister of Surroundings and Urbanization, Mehmet Ozhaseki, went even additional: promising a complete of 850,000 houses in September. However this week Erdogan had solely been capable of ship 46,000 houses within the earthquake zonesaying his authorities will ship 75,000 further houses in Hatay alone within the subsequent two months.
“Our aim is to carry collectively 15,000-20,000 houses and village halls with their beneficiaries each month within the subsequent interval,” he says said in Hatay, one of many hardest-hit provinces. “So by the top of the yr we may have delivered 200,000 houses, delivering on our promise.”
Erdogan added that Turkey withdrew $25 billion from its finances final yr to spend on reconstruction efforts and mentioned his authorities goals to return the affected cities to their previous, vibrant selves.
Hatay is the scene of probably the most high-profile and controversial subject in Turkey’s reconstruction: Antakya. The previous metropolis middle, recognized in historic instances as Antioch, has been largely destroyed. Many mosques, church buildings and monuments which can be centuries previous are not there.
Tugce Tezer, an city planner specializing in Antakya, mentioned throughout a panel in Istanbul on Saturday that a number of ministries had been concerned within the reconstruction, with totally different architectural plans underway for town, resulting in inconsistent efforts. She complained that, for instance, rubble assortment contractors have improperly dealt with poisonous asbestos-filled cement, contaminating the speedy setting the place individuals nonetheless dwell and work.
After the earthquake, the federal government made a take care of the contractors, permitting them to gather something of worth from the constructing supplies discovered within the rubble, resembling iron.
Regardless of the settlement specifying that this course of can solely be carried out in sure areas exterior cities, removed from inhabitants facilities, many corporations nonetheless type the fabric on website. without using waterreleasing the chemical that may shorten lives with attainable lung illnesses.
“The particles is sadly discharged into the gorgeous valleys of Hatay,” Tezer mentioned. “They’re burying agricultural areas and pastures and destroying what makes Antakya, which is primarily an agricultural manufacturing middle.”
Antakya plans doubtful
There may be now a consortium main the reconstruction and restoration efforts in Antakya’s historic metropolis. led by the Turkey Design Basis and its companions, the Turkish architectural agency DB Mimarlik and the British Foster + Companions, in addition to the London-based Bjarke Ingels Group (BIG).
The consortium is engaged on a grasp plan and detailed reconstruction work for the traditional metropolis of Antakya. However there may be additionally a separate space within the middle of Antakya, on the west facet of the Orontes River, that has been declared a ‘reserve space’ by the federal government.
The land of roughly 50,000 displaced residents from this reserve space could now be redesigned and rebuilt by the federal government, and it isn’t sure that they are going to be resettled in the identical space. The regulation makes it clear that beneficiaries can get hold of housing of the identical worth and measurement elsewhere in Hatay, as a substitute of within the reservation from which they’ve been evicted.
There isn’t a indication what sort of venture will probably be constructed on this reserve space, which was designated earlier than the earthquakes. Municipalities in Hatay formally approved the zoning plans drawn up earlier than the catastrophe, which unusually acquired the help of all political events represented within the native assemblies.
Sarkan Koc, a metropolis planner in Hatay, has mentioned that the accredited plans for redevelopment within the province solely require buildings to face up to earthquakes of magnitude 7, whereas one of many first shocks reached magnitude 7.8 on February 6, indicating that the plans weren’t severe. Many be aware that to this point nobody has held a authorities official answerable for the collapse of components of buildings in southern Turkey.
In line with Human Rights Watch, lawsuits have been launched towards actual property builders, constructing managers and technical workers in current months.
“However no official, elected mayor or metropolis council member has but been delivered to justice for his or her position in approving numerous development initiatives that fell far in need of secure constructing requirements. or as a result of they haven’t taken measures to guard individuals dwelling in buildings recognized to have structural issues in a area with a excessive threat of seismic exercise,” the report mentioned.
Erdogan additionally urged that native elections in March would additional delay efforts to restore the catastrophic harm. The president accused Hatay’s opposition-allied mayor, Lutfu Savas, of failing to adequately coordinate with the central authorities, exposing partisan political tensions as essential native elections method.
“I am telling you a truth now: if the central authorities and the native authorities do not be part of arms and present solidarity, nothing will come to that metropolis,” Erdogan mentioned. said. “Did it come to Hatay? At present, Hatay is left as a stranger, Hatay is unhappy and sadly the present native authorities in Hatay is ruined after this earthquake incident. The place is the mayor?”